Wednesday, November 18

UC Regents hear research on standardized testing requirements, diversity


SAT test books are pictured. UCLA and UC Berkeley have admitted more diverse applicants since the University stopped considering standardized testing in first-year undergraduate admissions, researchers said at the UC Board of Regents’ Tuesday meeting. (Daily Bruin file photo)


This post was updated Nov. 17 at 11:53 p.m.

UCLA and UC Berkeley have admitted a more diverse pool of applicants since they stopped considering standardized testing in first-year undergraduate admissions, but student readiness has declined, researchers said at the UC Board of Regents’ Tuesday meeting. 

Two researchers presented data related to student outcomes and standardized testing to the regents at their bimonthly meeting held at UC San Francisco’s Mission Bay Conference Center on Tuesday. After thousands of professors called on the UC to revoke its test-blind policy, citing declining student preparedness, the regents announced the UC Academic Senate would recommend whether or not to reinstate the tests by June 2027.

[Related: UC Academic Senate to decide on recommending SAT, ACT reinstatement by June 2027]

Between 2019 and 2025, the share of underrepresented minority admits at UCLA and UC Berkeley rose from 22% to 26% and 20% to 26%, respectively, said Jesse Rothstein, a professor of public policy and economics at UC Berkeley. He added that because disparities in standardized testing results exist along socioeconomic and racial lines, GPAs are a fairer predictor of academic success.  

However, John Friedman, an economics and international and public affairs professor at Brown University, raised another point based on his research: Students with strong high school GPAs but low standardized test scores are more likely to struggle academically in college. He cited his own data analysis of admissions and academic performance in the Ivy League and at other elite private universities. 

“These disparities reflect underlying disparities and inequality in school quality and other environmental factors that affect students from different backgrounds,” Friedman said. “They are not biases in the test itself.”

The University paused its standardized testing requirements in 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic and stopped considering the tests altogether in 2021. 

More than 2,000 UC faculty signed a May letter calling on the University to reinstate standardized testing requirements for first-year undergraduate admissions to STEM programs, citing a lack of math preparedness. More than 900 humanities and social sciences faculty signed a similar letter in June calling on the University to consider bringing back the verbal reasoning portions of the SAT and ACT.

[Related: Hundreds of UC faculty call to reinstate SAT, ACT requirements for STEM applicants]

Friedman said standardized testing can predict long-term outcomes beyond college, such as income, employment and graduate school attendance. While test scores vary between students of different financial or cultural backgrounds, disparities can be tied to societal inequities rather than standardized testing itself, he added.

Declining student preparedness is a nationwide concern and cannot be attributed to the SAT alone, Rothstein said.

“The SAT derives its predictive power by measuring student background,” Rothstein said. “It essentially turns this measure of background that we wouldn’t want to use directly in admissions into something that looks like it’s meritocratic but isn’t.”

Researchers also addressed the regents’ questions about alternatives to the SAT and ACT.

The Smarter Balanced Assessment Consortium – which the UC Academic Senate is considering as an alternative to the SAT and ACT – could have similar predictive value to other standardized tests, though there is less evidence that differences between scores are associated with socioeconomic gaps, Rothstein said.

The SBAC test is currently administered to all California public school students in 11th grade.

[Related: UC Academic Senate to consider SBAC as potential SAT, ACT alternative]

“The University of California committed a long time ago to holistic review,” Rothstein said. “It’s very hard for faculty members to really see what the trade-offs are in the way that the admissions offices can see.”


Comments are supposed to create a forum for thoughtful, respectful community discussion. Please be nice. View our full comments policy here.